Episode 8
· 01:06:28
Lessons 7a, 7b and 7c, about 66 minutes.
0:00 Lesson 7a: The case against the gut, and the quarrel it started. The strongest case against fast judgment, and the fight it started. Daniel Kahneman's officer assessments in the Israeli army and the "illusion of validity," Paul Meehl's clinicians and the simple formulas that matched or beat them, Tversky and Kahneman's three mental shortcuts (representativeness, availability, anchoring), Gerd Gigerenzer's argument that many "biases" shrink when problems are put as frequencies, Kahneman and Tversky's 1996 reply, an "adversarial collaboration" that settled nothing but showed a better way to argue, and two famous findings, behavioral priming and ego depletion, that shrank in larger replications.
24:20 Lesson 7b: When can you trust your gut? Newborn-ward nurses who sensed infection before the blood tests showed it, Gary Klein's fire commanders acting on recognition (and Klein's own warning that his interviews never showed whether their decisions were good), and the 2009 paper in which Kahneman and Klein expected to disagree and mostly didn't: skilled intuition is recognition, it needs a world with real regularities and a chance to learn them with feedback, and the feeling of confidence can't tell good intuitions from bad. Then what newcomers and experts each see, and where the two men still split: checklists, and whether guarding against error gets in the way of insight.
45:47 Lesson 7c: Simple rules, and signals from the body. Expert handball players whose first choice beat their considered one, while novice golfers did better with more time. Gigerenzer's case that simple rules can beat complex models where prediction is hard, the Michigan doctors who learned which cues mattered, and the limits Gigerenzer sets himself. Then the Iowa card game and the somatic marker hypothesis: the 1997 claim that the body knows first, Maia and McClelland's 2004 challenge, and the Iowa group's reply that the hypothesis is about emotion helping thought, conscious or not. It ends by asking what the whole module says about barely formed instincts.
Listen to Adam's Podcast using one of many popular podcasting apps or directories.