Episode 7
· 01:06:09
Lessons 6a, 6b and 6c, about 66 minutes.
0:00 Lesson 6a: Making ideas and picking one. The two halves of creative work: making ideas and choosing among them. J. P. Guilford's 1950 address, the Torrance Tests of creative thinking and the debate over whether they measure creativity, and experiments finding that people are poor at picking their own best ideas, including Justin Berg's finding that the idea people ranked second often turned out best.
22:58 Lesson 6b: What newcomers see, and what experts see. What do newcomers and outsiders see that experts don't, and who judges their ideas? How familiar solutions block better ones (the Einstellung effect, even in strong chess players), outsiders solving problems on the InnoCentive contest site (most of whom held PhDs), how expert grant reviewers scored novel proposals, a study of who best predicts which novel circus acts succeed, and Benjamin Jones on the growing "burden of knowledge."
44:11 Lesson 6c: Fresh eyes, and how long they last. The newcomer's own kind of insight, and how long it lasts. Erik Dane's theory of cognitive entrenchment, Pamela Hinds's "curse of expertise" experiments (people only a little way along predicted beginners' difficulty best), Matt Beane's fieldwork on fresh eyes and juniors teaching seniors, and a study of junior consultants new to GPT-4 who misread its risks.
Listen to Adam's Podcast using one of many popular podcasting apps or directories.